The inquiry

On September 24, the Federal Trade Commission opened a public rulemaking inquiry into whether online platforms should face new obligations when their advertising systems help government and business impersonation scams reach consumers.

This is not a final rule, and the FTC has not found that every platform or every optimization tool is unlawful. The agency is asking for evidence before deciding whether to amend its Impersonation Rule, propose a separate rule or take other action.

The scale behind the inquiry is concrete. The FTC says consumers submitted more than one million imposter-scam reports for 2025 and reported nearly $3.5 billion in losses. Nearly 30% of people who reported losing money to scammers said the contact began on social media; those reported losses totaled $2.1 billion.

What the advertising tools do

A scam ad does not necessarily travel through a platform as a static message. Advertising tools can assemble creative elements, test combinations, select audiences and optimize delivery toward people considered likely to respond.

Those capabilities are valuable to legitimate advertisers. The FTC’s concern is that the same machinery may also make impersonation campaigns more effective. Its notice describes a structural mismatch: platforms can earn revenue when ads are created, displayed or clicked, while victims bear the financial cost when a fraudulent ad succeeds.

The central question is therefore larger than whether a platform removed a scam after someone reported it. It is whether the system helped decide who saw the deception, how it was presented and where it was placed before the victim ever encountered it.

That distinction matters. A person may believe they are evaluating a bank alert, government notice or familiar business offer on its face. In reality, the message may have arrived through an optimization system trained to find the next person most likely to act.

Where responsibility begins

Trust online is not only about whether content is true. It is also about what the distribution system rewards.

The FTC has not yet decided what platforms should be required to do. Its questions include advertiser vetting, monitoring, investigation, removal and discipline. Any eventual rule would require further legal steps.

But the inquiry makes one part of the system visible now: when platforms optimize delivery, they are not merely hosting the message. They are helping determine who receives it and when. That does not make every resulting harm intentional. It does make the architecture relevant to responsibility.

The useful question for any persuasive message is: Why did this reach me, in this form, at this moment?

Trust online depends not only on whether a message is true, but also on what the distribution system rewards.

Sources

Look at your own path

Take the Digital Influence Test and trace one recent decision back to what first appeared, what stood out and what was missing.

Read further

The Silent Influencer: Pulling Back the Curtain on How AI Is Using You follows these hidden influences through everyday decisions and shows readers where deliberate choice can begin again.

Buy The Silent Influencer on Amazon
Don OsmundAuthor of The Silent Influencer