Before the gallery opens

On November 10, ArtStation changed its gallery before a visitor chooses anything. Creators must now say whether a project is primarily made with generative AI, combines it with other methods, or contains none at all. The default setting hides work declared as AI-made. It also applies the strictest setting to work the service suspects may have been made that way.

This is not a ban. The work can remain on ArtStation, and a visitor can change the setting. But the first view now begins with some work already missing. The declaration does more than describe a project. It helps decide whether the project appears.

The label comes before the work

Labels usually arrive after we see something. They tell us where a shirt was made, what is in the food, or who paid for an advertisement. ArtStation has moved the label one step earlier. A visitor may never reach the point of reading it because the label has already kept the work out of sight.

The service also lets people report projects they believe used generative AI without saying so. Those reports do not automatically label or remove the work. ArtStation says it considers them with other signs when deciding what its filters should hide. The creator’s declaration, the tags attached to the project, reports from other users and the visitor’s own settings now meet before the gallery is assembled.

ArtStation made a second change that matters to artists in a different way. Its NoAI setting is now applied by default to new projects, older uploads and profiles. That setting tells others that the work may not be used to train an AI system. One default limits who sees certain work. The other states how artists allow their own work to be used.

Permission is becoming part of the picture

A related change arrived a day earlier in advertising. Ogilvy and Creative Artists Agency introduced ECHO, a service that can turn one celebrity shoot into dozens of approved variations. The person whose face or voice appears must opt in, and every finished advertisement requires that person’s approval before it is released. Cleared advertisements carry a visible notice: “[Name] Approved | Recreated with AI.”

ArtStation and ECHO are dealing with different kinds of work, but both put permission ahead of visibility. ArtStation begins by keeping certain projects out of view unless the visitor asks to see them. ECHO keeps an advertisement from going out until the person whose likeness it uses approves it.

That changes the purpose of disclosure. It is no longer only a note attached to something we have already seen. It can decide whether we see the thing at all.

The choice has already started

A person opening ArtStation may believe the choice begins with the pictures on the screen. It begins earlier, with the setting that decided which pictures were allowed onto that screen. The same is true when an approved digital likeness reaches an advertisement. The public sees the finished image after the important decisions about permission and presentation have already been made.

This is a useful question to carry elsewhere: before I chose among the things in front of me, who decided what would be allowed to appear?

Before I chose among the things in front of me, who decided what would be allowed to appear?

Sources

Look at your own path

Take the Digital Influence Test and trace one recent decision back to what first appeared, what stood out and what was missing.

Read further

The Silent Influencer: Pulling Back the Curtain on How AI Is Using You follows these hidden influences through everyday decisions and shows readers where deliberate choice can begin again.

Buy The Silent Influencer on Amazon
Don OsmundAuthor of The Silent Influencer