Where the link leads

Ask a shopping assistant where to buy something and the answer can sound settled: here is the store, here is the link, here is where to go next. A study released this week found that some of those destinations were fake, inactive or otherwise risky.

Podqi, a company that protects brands from imitation, tested ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity with five shopping questions about 151 brands. The company reviewed 6,795 answers gathered during two rounds of testing in September.

A recommendation carries more weight than a search result

Podqi classified a website as risky when it appeared to imitate a brand, sell suspected counterfeits or lead to a dead address that could later be registered by someone else. Sites in those categories appeared in about 9 percent of the answers.

The results varied by service. Risky sites appeared in 15 percent of Perplexity’s answers, 8 percent of ChatGPT’s and 4 percent of Gemini’s. Among the answers that included a risky site, 57 percent recommended it as a place to shop, 34 percent mentioned it without comment and 9 percent warned the shopper away.

Podqi sells protection against the problem it studied, and the results come from questions the company wrote rather than ordinary shoppers’ conversations. That matters when judging the reach of the findings. It does not erase the problem the test exposed: an unsafe destination can appear inside an answer that sounds as usable as any other shopping advice.

The answer removes a useful moment of doubt

A page of search results gives a shopper several links to compare. A direct answer can make one destination feel chosen already. The assistant has reduced the list, described the store and placed the next step within reach.

The study found the greatest risk in questions about regional websites. Some brands do not operate a separate store in every country. When an assistant supplies an address that looks like the missing regional site, the shopper may have little reason to suspect that the brand never created it.

Smaller brands were affected more often than large companies. Their official stores may be less familiar, and fewer reliable pages may be available to correct a convincing imitation.

Check the destination before trusting the direction

A shopping answer can save time without proving that the store it names belongs to the brand. Before entering personal or payment information, open the brand’s main website and follow its own links to regional stores or authorized sellers.

The useful question is simple: did the brand lead me here, or did the answer merely make the link look official?

Did the brand lead me here, or did the answer merely make the link look official?

Sources

Look at your own path

Take the Digital Influence Test and trace one recent decision back to what first appeared, what stood out and what was missing.

Read further

The Silent Influencer: Pulling Back the Curtain on How AI Is Using You follows these hidden influences through everyday decisions and shows readers where deliberate choice can begin again.

Buy The Silent Influencer on Amazon
Don OsmundAuthor of The Silent Influencer